Apple Music vs. Tidal: Which Is Best for You?

Part 1. Overview of Apple Music and Tidal

Apple Music

Apple Music debuted in 2015 as a subscription-based streaming service offering a vast library of music, curated playlists, and seamless integration with Apple's ecosystem. It quickly gained traction thanks to its strong focus on personalized music discovery and its deep integration with Apple products like iPhones, iPads, Macs, and Apple Watches. Apple Music has since expanded its features, adding Lossless Audio and Spatial Audio, providing users with a richer and more immersive listening experience. These upgrades have made Apple Music a competitive option for audiophiles within the Apple ecosystem.

Tidal

Tidal, on the other hand, launched in 2014 with a focus on audiophile-quality streaming but rebranded a year later after Jay-Z took over the company. With a strong emphasis on supporting artists, Tidal appeals to those who prioritize sound quality and exclusive content. Tidal offers HiFi and MQA audio formats, delivering high-resolution sound for audiophiles, though it requires compatible hardware or software to fully enjoy the MQA files. Unlike some services, Tidal doesn't charge extra for its high-resolution content, making it an attractive option for users seeking premium audio without hidden costs.

Part 2. Comparison of Apple Music and Tidal

Apple Music vs. Tidal: User Experience and Interface

We started with something light: switching between the apps while sipping on our morning coffee. Apple Music feels built for speed, with polished, seamless navigation. From the moment we opened the app on the iPhone, everything felt intuitive - like it was designed for someone who's been using Apple products their whole life. We jumped between devices - iPhone to Mac, then to HomePod - and it just worked, no hiccups.

Tidal, on the other hand, offers a more minimalist design. It feels fresh but slightly less user-friendly at first. As we moved through its interface, we couldn't shake the feeling that something was missing. Once we started digging into the features, the customization options were great, but it took a few extra taps to get where we wanted. Overall, the experience felt a bit less fluid compared to Apple Music, especially when switching between mobile and desktop. It's not that Tidal is bad - Apple Music just has that effortless feel that's almost second nature if you already use Apple devices.

Apple Music vs. Tidal: Music Library and Content

Next, we dove into the catalog. Apple Music's library is vast, with over 100 million songs and playlists tailored to your taste. We tested everything from contemporary pop to obscure classical tracks and didn't hit a wall. The curated playlists made it feel personal - like Apple Music was listening to us while we were listening to it. Jumping between genres was a breeze, always leading to new discoveries.

Tidal, however, brings a different vibe. While its library is similar in size, it feels like there's a touch more exclusivity. Tidal shines with its focus on high-res audio and exclusive artist content. We stumbled upon rarer tracks—like early album releases from indie artists - and exclusive behind-the-scenes videos that Apple Music doesn't offer. Tidal's artist-first curation feels like diving into a deeper world. While Apple Music offers quantity, Tidal adds a layer of personality.

Apple Music vs. Tidal: Sound Quality

Then came the real test - sound. We started with a track we know well: Radiohead's Everything In Its Right Place. On Apple Music, it was clean and crisp, with each electronic note fitting perfectly, like pieces of a puzzle. But switching to Tidal revealed something different. The low end was more present, more grounded. The bass had a texture that filled the room, making the track feel warmer and fuller - almost immersive.

That's not to say Apple Music lagged behind. Its lossless audio, especially in the Hi-Res tier, delivered remarkable clarity that sometimes edged ahead - particularly with classical music like Beethoven's 9th Symphony. The detail in Apple Music was striking, with every instrument distinct. Still, it wasn't as lush as Tidal's rendition of the same track. Tidal's MQA felt rich and warm, but Apple Music's uncompressed clarity brought orchestral depth into focus. For pure warmth, though, Tidal had the edge.

Apple Music vs. Tidal: Pricing and Plans

Both services impressed us with their sound and content, so next, we looked at pricing. Apple Music keeps it straightforward: $10.99 per month for the individual plan, with no free tier and no unnecessary extras. For the price, it's a solid offering, especially with its seamless integration across Apple devices, making it a natural choice for those already in the ecosystem.

Tidal, however, offers more variety. Its standard Individual plan matches Apple Music at $10.99, but adding the DJ Extension requires an extra $9 for both Individual and Student plans. That premium price is worth it only if you're serious about top-tier sound and exclusive features. For those looking for a no-fuss service, Apple Music's simplicity is hard to beat. But if you're an audiophile with the right gear, Tidal's offering can justify the additional cost - if you can hear the difference.

Apple Music vs. Tidal: Device Compatibility

Finally, we tested both platforms across devices. Unsurprisingly, Apple Music worked seamlessly within its ecosystem. We switched between iPhones, Macs, and even a HomePod mini, with flawless syncing. Integration with Siri made playback control feel natural. If you're already in the Apple ecosystem, Apple Music is the easy choice.

Tidal, however, isn't limited to Apple. Its app works on a wide range of devices - from Android to smart speakers and even TVs. We tested it on a Google Home and Amazon Echo, and both streamed Tidal without issues. The catch? To make the most of Tidal's high-fidelity sound, you need the right gear - specialized DACs or high-res audio players. With Apple Music, your standard iPhone or MacBook works effortlessly, while Tidal requires extra hardware to shine.

Part 3. Apple Music and Tidal: Which is the Best Streaming Service?

Overall, we found both Apple Music and Tidal impressive in their own ways, but deciding between them is no simple task.

The first thing to note is that both services deliver outstanding sound quality, but the differences may be subtle, depending on your setup and preferences. On high-end systems, Tidal's MQA tracks offered slightly more depth and clarity, especially for acoustic and live recordings. Apple Music's lossless audio, however, was consistently reliable, providing rich, uncompressed sound across various devices.

In everyday listening - like using standard headphones or streaming in the car - the differences became negligible. Across genres and tracks, Tidal occasionally edged out Apple Music, but the gap was too minor to influence most listeners.

Does this mean one service is definitively better? Not really. Ultimately, the choice depends on factors like catalog size, device compatibility, pricing, and ease of use rather than marginal audio differences. If you're an audiophile with the right gear, Tidal's premium tiers may be worth the investment. But for those who value intuitive design, seamless integration, and excellent sound, Apple Music is hard to beat.

For added flexibility, third-party tools can help you expand playback options. ViWizard Apple Music Converter lets Apple Music users convert tracks into widely compatible formats like MP3, while ViWizard Tidal Music Converter offers similar support for Tidal users.

In the end, both services are strong contenders. Your choice will likely come down to personal preferences, how the service fits into your daily life, and what matters most to you - whether it's catalog variety, price, or convenience.

Conclusion

Both of the two software provides users with a variety of music, but the songs downloaded from them are protected to prevent playing on MP3 players, Samsung TV, Soundbar, Android, etc. If you want to play Apple Music on your portable devices without limitations, ViWizard Apple Music Converter may your good assistant. This Music converter can is good for you to convert protected Apple Music to MP3 for playback offline forever.

Key Features of ViWizard Audio Converter

Free Trial Free Trial

* Security verified. 5, 481,347 people have downloaded it.

• Convert songs, albums, and playlists from Apple Music to MP3
• Remove DRM protection from Apple Music, iTunes, and Audible
• Save the converted audios with the original quality and ID3 tags
• Support the conversion of up to 100 audio formats to others